As an OG listener, I’m dumbfounded as to how there isn’t a consensus 5 star ranking here. In a jungle of disingenuous money grab podcasting, Matt and Scad are a shining light of joyous sincerity greatly lacking in this medium. I’ll listen to every episode you all put out. Read the phone book if you want. Na zdraví!

I stumbled upon this podcast. I was a late bloomer and trying to find my way into a group of people who would let me obsessively talk about books. They invited me to ASOM and I have formed some amazing friendships. Davis Fingers should be getting a lot of credit in this fandom. They have brought SO MANY nerds together. ♥️♥️♥️ they brought me to my nerd family. Forever grateful and will never leave these guys.

I’m halfway through DWD in my first read through of ASOIAF, and I’ve been listening to Davos’ Fingers all along the way. I can’t say enough good things about the podcast. They help my understanding and appreciation of the books, and I will definitely listen again to the Davos after Dark sections once I finish the books. If you’ve been looking for a ASOIAF podcast to listen to while you read look no further.

I am rereading ASOIAF and found this podcast to follow along. Found this so fun and entertaining as someone who does not watch the show or read any of the theories/fandom online. I just read the books and enjoy them as is. Once a Brooke left I had a hard time staying engaged I was so sad! The dynamic changed and I missed her perspective and personality. :( Matt and Scad are still cool to listen to, but feels like a different show.

So on a scale of The Phantom Menance to Empire, they are definitely Empire! I love the new format they have started where they bring in members of their Kahlasar to guest host. What a great way to incorporate their patrons. I love the way it just sounds like old friends sitting down and talking through the night. I appreciate that they chat about other things and bring in real life expiriences to the podcast. I found this podcast late, but so glad I did!

I absolutely love you guys, but your guest on the latest episode is ridiculously annoying, trying WAY too hard to be ‘funny’, even if she is the only one laughing. Such a disappointment, i don’t know how you guys managed to eek out 3 hours of content dealing with this chick. Oh woah she cusses and makes mean jokes about her kids radical she’s such a live wire! Ugh please fellas I can’t even listen to this episode, don’t have her on again she truly is unbearable. I’m sorry it took this for me to finally write a review 😑 5 stars for Davis Fingers, negative 5 stars for her

Y’all are my favorite podcast and I’ve listened twice over while I read the books twice as well! When the books are done and all our questions are answered, I hope you continue this podcast! Maybe even do the Witcher or name in the wind? Love y’all

Listened to a few episodes all the way through but after ep 107 I won’t listen anymore. The intro was over 30 min. which I didn’t love. The guest they had on kept calling Bran dumb in a really mean spirited way. He’s literally only 8 in the book. The other hosts didn’t seem bothered by it.

Matt and Scad do something that is really intriguing to me. They’re very relaxed as they work through chapters, having a nice chat with their best buddy about a story they share a passion for. In this way, the podcast is easy to listen to (even therapeutic). However, they also provide top notch analysis even in a very relaxed setting. Most importantly, both are fantastic fathers and kind people who have brought a tremendous amount of joy to The Fandom.

I wasn’t a huge fan at first but this pod has really grown on me. Brooke’s feminist zeal dies down after awhile, and I definitely miss her on the show now. The musical intros are really hit or miss IMO, ranging from mute-worthy (Arya, Cat) to downright catchy (Jon), and at this point I’d rather have them than not. I also tend to skip through the occasional long tangents of moral pontificating prevalent in the Feast/Dance episodes. Quality show though all told.